I ran very extensive tests on all of these Z-Wave motion detectors. Here were my results on the SmartThings hub. Please note that your results may vary. In all cases, I tried very hard to make all motion sensors work in the hub.
PLEASE NOTE: The results were VERY different in Wink Hub 2. Please check out the Wink Hub 2 results page.
The following link is based on my test performed in April 2018.
| Rank | Manufacturer | Model | ~Price | Detect Range | Detect Distance | Power Source | Sensors | Purchase Link | Other Comments |
| #1a | Zooz | ZSE40 v2 | $38 | 120o | 30′ | CR123 | Motion Temp Light1 Vibration1 |
  |
Top performer in SmartThings v2 |
| #1b | Zooz | ZSE29 | $38 | 120o | 30′ | AA@2 USB |
Outdoor Motion |   |
Top performer in SmartThings v2 |
| #2 | Ecolink | PIRZWAVE2.5-ECO | $37 | 90o | 45′ | CR123 | Motion |   |
Very fast, very reliable |
| #3 | CoolCam | NAS-MS03 | $33 | 90o | 21′ | CR123 | Motion Light1 |
  |
Very fast, very reliable |
| #4 | Dome3 | DMMS1 | $35 | 110o | 45′ | CR123 | Motion Light1 |
  |
Very fast, very reliable |
| #5 | Aeotec | Multisensor 6 in 1 | $59 | 120o | 15′ | CR123@2 USB |
Motion Temp Humidity Light UV Vibration1 |
  |
Optional recessor kit available – great value for money if you need the other sensors! |
| #6 | Fibaro | FMGS-001 | $60 | 90o | 21′ | CR123 | Motion Temp Light Vibration |
  |
|
| #7 | GE Embrighten | Z-Wave Plus Smart Motion Sensor | $38 | 180o | 45′ | CR123@2 USB |
Motion |   |
Slower average response times than hoped for |
| #8 | Monoprice | Z-Wave Plus Smart Motion Sensor | $30 | 120o | 30′ | CR123@2 | Motion Temp Light1 Humidity1 |
  |
Slower average response times than hoped for |
| #9 | HomeSeer2 | HS-MS100 | $29 | CR123@2 USB |
Motion Light |
  |
Did not work in SmartThings for me |
1 – Features require a custom device handler to be available in the SmartThings hub.
2 – Did not work in the SmartThings hub for me. Device came in as an Open/Close sensor, but would never trigger or change state when motion was detected.
3 – Top performer in the Wink Hub 2.